In the poem “Theme for English
B,” Langston Hughes asks “So will my page be colored that I write?” I can’t
help but wonder if my writing will be gay. How much does our experience, our
gender, our sexual preference, color our pages?
Obviously, when I write
lesbian characters I come to it from personal experience. I don’t know all
lesbians but I have a first row seat into lesbian life. As a result, I should
be able to create complex lesbian characters.
Despite that
experience, I find writing lesbian characters difficult. I struggle to find
Cindy’s voice; she is the young intern at the newspaper in the novel I am writing.
Is it because she is too much like me that I can’t see her clearly? Or do I
have too much material to choose from? Or does my memory of how young lesbians talk
and act in the late 1970s escape me? I write female characters who are straight,
and they are distinct in motivations, language, and conflicts. So it is
something about lesbians I struggle with.
Ironically, I have
always found male characters easier to write. It isn’t simply that I find them
fascinating; I find women fascinating too. I can‘t say that I understand men or
women any better than the other. I don’t identify with men more, though at 12,
I had a lot more in common with them than I did my schoolgirl chums. I just can
get into male characters quickly, and they are different from one another.
So what role does being
a lesbian play in my writing? Am I supposed to write gay because I am gay? I am
a lesbian, but I live in a world that is predominately straight, and
extraordinarily male-centric in politics, literature, and power. So I walk in
both worlds, my own private world and that of straight, male-centric society. I
am the Other, just like the African American, Native American, and even the
woman writer. As the Other, we usually are expected to normalize our world while
capturing its flavor and uniqueness.
Preston has been called
a stereotypical gay character by some straight readers as he hates sports,
loves to cook, and is a mama’s boy. There are men, straight and gay, who fit
this description. Am I stereotyping or capturing a reality?
I do wonder how the gay
community will react to Preston as it prefers gays to be depicted as “normal,”
like straight characters – if you can call them normal – concerned with daily
life, work, and love, not drag shows, bars, and sexual hook ups. Not like
Preston, who in the years just prior to AIDS/HIV, spends his time cruising and only
looking for sex. He does settle down in the end, so maybe that will satisfy the
uneasy reader.
I doubt “straight”
writers wonder how their sexuality affects their depiction of their world. They
probably don’t feel an obligation to the “straight” community to depict it
fairly and justly.